Friday, May 21, 2004

The Undoing of America

"Four hostile newspapers are more to be feared than a thousand bayonets."

    - Napoleon Bonaparte (1768-1821), French emperor

After writing yesterday's post about the media's coverage of Iraq, I ran across another column related to what I was attempting to convey. Initially, I thought of adding it as an update to what I'd already said, but it's substantive enough to merit an entry of its own.

It was written by Mort Kondracke, Executive Editor of Roll Call and was posted on the RealClearPolitics website. Kondracke believes that Congress and the media are on a path to talking Americans into a defeat in Iraq:

"The media--unperturbed by mistakenly likening both the Afghan war and last year's invasion of Iraq to Vietnam--focuses overwhelmingly on the bad news coming out of Iraq. There is plenty of bad news--but there is also much good, and it is being almost completely ignored."

He contrasts what is now happening in the Middle East to what happened during the Vietnam conflict in the 1960's:


In 1968--by no accident, a U.S. presidential election year--the Viet Cong launched a massive countrywide offensive in South Vietnam, invading the U.S. Embassy complex in the process. By every military measure, U.S. and South Vietnamese forces devastated the Communist forces...Yet the U.S. media reported the episode as a U.S. defeat, helping convince the American establishment that the war was unwinnable. In this respect, there is a real danger that Iraq could become like Vietnam--a self-inflicted defeat."

Kondracke highlights some of the negative aspects of allowing this to happen:

"...if Congress and the media raise doubts that Bush can 'finish the job,' then Iraqis--who already have good reason to doubt American resolve, given our performance during and after the 1991 Gulf War--will lose all faith that they can have a stable country...The consequences of failure will be disastrous--not just for Bush, but for Iraqis, for America, for the Middle East and for civilization itself."

Yes, the media and Congress could turn this into another Vietnam.  Al-Qaeda and other terrorist organizations, as well as most of the middle eastern countries like Syria and Iran, already believe that the U.S. is a paper tiger, that we have no resolve for remaining in an extended conflict that becomes messy and politically complicated. The North Vietnamese knew that and used it to their advantage in the 60's, just as the terrorists in Iraq, Syria and Iran know it today and are using it to their advantage as we speak. They realize they can't win militarily, but believe they can prevail politically if they can hang on until we become impatient. If you watch the evening news or read the morning paper, you'd believe we're at that point already.


If Americans allow the naysayers in the media and those in Congress to convince us with their whining and negative reporting that we should pull out of Iraq before our mission is accomplished, it will be catastrophic. The Iraqis who supported us will have hell to pay, our country will lose all credibility with our allies, and we'll become completely vulnerable to those who wish us harm. As in the years prior to 9/11 when we were being hit time after time by our enemies and retaliating only minimally, every terrorist in the world will know they can be as vicious and destructive as they please with us and we will do nothing but stick our heads in the sand while they shove another nuke up our posterior.

That, my friends, will be the sorriest state of affairs we could ever find ourselves in, and our mostly anti-Bush media can stick out their chests and proclaim to the world that they have succeeded once again in achieving their objectives--provided the cities from which they spew their "fair and balanced" broadcasts still exist.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

History is a funny thing.  Unless one is aware of it one tends to repeat it.  Our own war of independence fought over 200 years ago was one just like this one.  The only difference is were were the invaded not the invader.  It will prove to make all the difference in this war just as it did in Viet Nam.  We have declared a war on terror.  Terror is not a country but it is a state of mind, differing for each.  Intangibles--ideas have to be fought with intangibles and ideas not bombs! We also can't want something for someone else more that they want it for themselves.  It is really amazing how the "right" feels as though the good news isn't coming thru even though it is their war.  Maybe it is just the "left" that is willing to put themselves in harms way in this unholy mess so they can report all the bad stuff.  Why is that, do you suppose? Isn't a school opening worth a possible beheading?

Anonymous said...

Right on Ron!  Well said.  And to Sarah: I believe we are communicating quite well with the terrorists through our bombs as that seems to be the only language they understand!  Also you're correct about the "left" reporting the bad stuff as they will do anything, yes even put themselves in harms way, to bring down President Bush.  The only Iraqi's they seem to talk to are the one's who want us out of their country. They don't bother talking to the ones who are thanking their God that we're there.  But hey, why report something positive when it's not on your agenda.

Anonymous said...

If wars were like football games, where the enthusiasm of the crowd in the stands has an immediate effect on the adrenaline of the players, and where life and death is not at stake, smiley-face reporting about the war might make a difference.

But no amount of cheerful reporting can make the Iraqis love us, or change the fact that Americans are dying and the pro-torture zealots like Christian General Boykin are doing things that are devastating to the US political position in the Middle East.

Guys like Morton Kondracke would much rather whine about the alleged lack of pep and cheerfulness in The Media than admit that members of The Media like Kondracke himself got snookered like naive children by the likes of Iranian spy Ahmed Chalabi and their lying claims about non-existent "weapons of mass destruction".  If Kodracke and media war zealots like him had shown a little more sense of responsibility - and patriotism? - *before* the war, things might look at lot different for the US position in the Middle East and the Muslim world right now. - Bruce